You are hereForums / By Discipline / Mountain (off road) / MTB Gear / Surly Fat Bike

Surly Fat Bike


Chicken Legs's picture

By Chicken Legs - Posted on 14 January 2014

NB: Originally posted elsewhere on the Global Riders Network and appears via syndication.

I think I want a Surly Pugsly or Moonlander, who has experience with these bikes and wants to share? I have a Rat Ride and love it, also a 1x1 frame gathering dust that has a pile of parts lying around it that need bolting on (standard 29 rims).

Tags
Pete B's picture

I hired a Moonlander in Hanmer Springs, NZ a couple of weeks ago. The bike was set up with a 1x11 internally geared hub.

It was one of the most fun times on a mountain bike I've had in a long time. They climb really well and once you get used to how far you can lean them over, they'll hammer through any flowing singletrack. I did a few small jumps on it that was fun but didn't think it was really meant for being airborne.

If I had a big enough garage and the spare funds, I'd definitely add one to my stable.

Chicken Legs's picture

Thanks Pete, did it have a suspension fork or was it rigid?

Do you think it would suit the trails around Orange?

Pete B's picture

No suspension on the bike I hired.

Should go ok round Kinross, the downhill section towards the car park would be great.

Let me know if you get one, I'm in orange in a few weeks time and would like to see it go there.

chrischris's picture

Krampus. Far more suitable & manouverable than a Moonlander.

Some super fit guy came second in a 6hr XC race on a SS Krampus not long ago. Can't find the link...

Chicken Legs's picture

Not really sure the Krampus is fat enough and being a 29er it all feels a little dodgy. I've actually started to grow a beard just in case I get the bike sooner than later.

Pete B's picture

If you're going to get a fat bike, you may as well get the fattest.

Chicken Legs's picture

One vote for Moonlander it is. Will have to re think the bike rack at 4.8" tyres.

Hugor's picture

Agree with above. Half fat is no good for anybody.
I've got a Moonie with the Bud and Lou tyres set up tubeless.
Its a great bike. When they make some fat suspension forks that will fir 4.8 inch tyres it will be even better.

Harry's picture

Had one for about a month now (Kona WO) and have taken it on all types of trails, from sandy beach rides to single trail and even some reasonably technical. Ride with a group at times and don't have any issues keeping up. No suspension and run about 10 psi in 4" tyres which gives a comfortable ride (run lower on the sand). Also considered wider tyres and if I was only going to ride sand would have gone this option.

Surly make nice bikes but steel on the beach was an issue for me (WO is alloy) - have a look at http://www.murucycles.com/ Aussie made titanium if you're looking for a higher spec.

hawkeye's picture

Aido at Belrose Bikes has fitted a Lefty to his fatbike.

I believe rlcsport.com.au is selling Leftys already set up for fatbikes with longer steerer clamp brackets.

I have photos somewhere of Aido's bike.

Re: steel on the beach, aluminium will corrode in a salt environment too if the paint is breached, especially where it contacts other materials like steel bolts or carbon. That's why marine fittings tend to be stainless.

Hugor's picture

Yeh I've seen that mod. Never got used to the fugliness of lefty's though.
There's also the Eyre fork which is Aussie but it's not good for 4.8's but 4's fit fine.

http://www.saltedbikes.com.au/#!product/prd1/1305949571/eyre-fat-bike-suspension-fork

DudeistPriest's picture

I just took one of these for a test ride along some single track up near Newcastle. Bloody fantastic fun to ride and absolutely ate the single track. One of these will definitely be my next bike

http://www.murucycles.com/

Chicken Legs's picture

Being trying to hit the muru cycles website for a while and have only this week had success, even then its very clunky, love the idea of Ti and Aussie made but its not been made easy. Biggest issue is no direct link or availability to complete bikes.

hawkeye's picture

Can't see em when you're riding, too busy steering to look down there. I love how they go where you point them.

Back on topic... I think Arran Pearson rode a Muru on the Tour Divide. City Bike Depot was building it for him. It was a work of art. Didn't get to see the completed bike. Sad

I'm keen to give one a go at some stage.

The Brown Hornet's picture

Dunno if Muru's are Aussie made. I think they contract frame manufacture out to Asia. Anyway, they're based in the Blue Mtns, so as soon as the funds recover I'll be knocking on their door!

I have a mate with a Surly Pugsley and a Surly Krampus. Both have been Lefty-fied and he reckons the front fork ups the fun factor tenfold.

fairy1's picture

Errrr, Muru has the uber fantastic Wayne from Dirt Works working there, may just be a catalogue frame with a million percent markup, I'd do my research before getting anything from that guy.

grantd's picture

I haven't got any experience with fat bikes but this video may make you want one more.

http://youtu.be/FXrg0lkEJ6k

Fat bikes seem like a good choice for the rocky/sandy/grassy terrain they cover.

alanm's picture

...experience with fat bikes, I have both the Pugs and a Moonie, although the Pugs is in bits…..

Just did a ride with the Moonie, ~700 K's from Albany to Perth. Used beaches,(~100K's) Munda Biddi,(half way between Albany and Denmark through to Walpole) Dirt and bitumen. I was running a Lou and BFL combo, on the dirt I'd run the Lou on the rear and swap it over to the front on the bitumen, of which I did about 180K's of. I could cruise at 22Kph on the flat with little trouble but as soon as I hit a hill I could be down as low as 5Kph, where upon it was easier to get off and push due to balance issues. I ran ~25 PSI on the bitumen. The whole rig weighed in at 77Kg. The bike alone is 22 Kg, water was 8Kg and the trailer, empty, is 12Kg. One problem was the heat of the bitumen, there were some quite hot days while I was on the blacktop, in the AM all was good, I'd roll down the hills, sometimes touching 54Kph and then I'd roll quite a way up the other side but in the PM, I'd drop 10Kph off the downhill speed on comparable hills and damm near stop when I hit the bottom. Dirt was fine, I hit 50Kph on a logging track hill coming into the Frankland river area, that was a hoot.....Pea gravel and sand on the MB was a doddle, where others had to push, I rolled over, ran about 10/12 PSI in the rear and 8 PSI in the front. I tell you, there is some Shite sand on that part of the MB, particularly between Jinung Beigabup hut and Booner Mundak hut.

I think it's a great tourer although the gears aren't particularly well spread for touring and towing a trailet. I have a Rohloff that I intend to lace into the rear. The cluster didn't like being dunked in salt water and then left to it's own devices, I striped it today and the bearing cones are pitted. Surprisingly, the BB was quite free of rust or water, although the crank side bearing was feeling tired, but it was a bit iffy before I left. BTW, the bearings for the BB are easily obtainable from a local bearing shop. They are a 6805 2RS, coincidently they are the same as the bearings off a Maverick SC32 axle and I had some laying in my bits box. They are relatively easy to change. I missed having a front sus fork as it can give a hard hit when loaded and the pressures are up a bit. I'd be the first to fit a front sus fork if they could take a Lou. An USD fork would suit me best for the mounting of low boy style racks. I used to run a SC32 and Thudbuster on the Pugs, with racks, and it was very comfy over the long haul.

The Surly Nice rear rack will fit on the rear with a double set mod to the bottom pins, I've got one on mine.

The front Nice also fits on with the standard mounting gear, sits a bit far forward but I got used to it. The most I usually carry in the front panniers is 10Kg of water and a few bit and shits. It just helps balance the bike when towing the BOB Ibex. I've moded the BOB to take a BFL, but it's a tight fit. I'm going to build a new trailer based on ideas I've had touring, it'll be a lot lighter at about 4Kg. I only really carry my solar panel, battery and maybe a tent on the trailer. Keeping towed weight to a minimum is quite important, particularly in very soft terrain.

Here's a link to a 13 minute uncut / unedited video on that last trip. I'm too lazy to chop it up!!!

Enjoy! Smiling


http://youtu.be/zS1vuYt_t7o

Al.

Lukkyphil's picture

Hi there.

I have a Muru Wirtjana V2 coming in a couple of weeks (being shipped Friday). Definately a Wayne that I have been dealing with, no idea if its the "Wayne from Dirtworks".

As for the deal, well decent value for money. I priced up the build kit through Wiggle/CRC and not really anything in it for the trouble. That said I paid the deposit on 24/10/13, so will be a four month process. That said it was over Xmas, and they also had to evacuate their house in the Blue Mountains. Wayne is very aware of the timeframes, and has been really helpful in sorting things out to ensure that we get the bikes as fast as we can, when the Thomson gear which has been on backorder for two months hasn't arrived he is shipping the bikes with Ritchey so we can at least ride them. The last couple of cars I own have been factory orders with six month waits, and once I got the cars I haven't regretted the wait - and a $12K cheque back at the end of a three year lease made my wife even happier....

Saw a guy riding one near the Mundaring Weir Hotel, and stopped and quizzed him, and had a damn good look (nice welds and good quality), and then promptly ordered one. Much much lighter that a Surly...

That said I will be using it for Bikepacking, as I love doing the off road trips, and the fatbikes work really well for this. Check out the bags from www.bikebagdude.com, I am really pleased with them.

Fatboy's picture

I was riding Manly Dam recently and caught up with a guy riding a pretty cool looking fat bike so as you do, I stopped to chat about his bike.

Turns out he is the importer of the Diamant brand from Norway and had only just set up his business. He pointed me to his website which he said is still under construction. I just took a look now and it does have some detail on the models and some spec's.

www.diamantbikes.com.au

I'd never paid attention to fat bikes before but thought they were all heavy steel things with internal gears. The one he was riding was an alloy frame and XT equipped and looked like a whole lot of fun. I have his phone number so intend organising to have a ride on one next time I'm riding Manly Dam as he's a local there.

Chicken Legs's picture

Well I purchased a Pugsley and am loving it. The float on unformed terrain is amazing and fun factor even better.

Fatboy's picture

Finally after my comments I made in Feb I finally contacted James the importer of the Diamant Fat Bikes a few weeks ago and organised a ride around Manly Dam. He got me to meet him at his house about 3km from the dam where he showed me the 2 bikes we would be riding – a Mammut F4 (14.5kg) and F3 (11.5kg). The lighter one was XT equipped.

We had quite a bit of uphill road riding to get to the dam. My first surprise was I expected these big tyres with 10psi to make it a damn hard slog but all I kept saying to him was “wow” in disbelief at the pace on the road. The one thing I instantly found difficult though was when I was standing on the hills I found the front tyre doesn't like changing direction. As the front wheel zig zags a little when climbing it wants to track the way it is turning so requires a conscious effort to get it to change direction.

Once we arrived at the dam the first thing I noticed was how these big tyres just absorb all that sharp chattery rock. It felt like I was on a duallie yet this thing had rigid forks! When we hit the short climb leading up to the golf course entrance we smashed over the tree roots and past a few cross country riders and they seemed to take it as well as roadies do when I pass them on the road on my mountain bike… It was on!

After smashing all the way up to the top entrance where I felt the bike was nearly as quick as my normal ride we were pulled over by the other group just wanting to chat about the bikes. They also couldn't believe how quick these things moved. On the long descent from the top entrance I took it easy as I just wasn't sure how hard you could smash down the small drops with rigid forks. I found the traction on sandy corners amazing. I don’t know how good though as I didn't have the nerve to push it to its limits. The only problem I had was changing direction on slow bits. As the front wheel turns the nobs on the sides do the work and these are about 5cm from the centre of the tyre so changing direction requires moving the contact point with the ground through say 10cm of movement which isn't subtle like on a 2” tyre.

On the way back to his house James was telling me he had sold a number of these bikes in QLD where you can hire them to ride on sand dunes and was packing a shipment to go to Thredbo for Winter. It left me thinking I had fun at Manly Dam but imagine how much more fun on soft sand or snow…?

LadyToast's picture

Adrian at Belrose is selling is old fat bike, the one with the lefty. The price is extremely tempting.

He's built a new carbon framed fatty with custom wheels that are even wider I believe, it only weighs 11KG too.

Adrian is well worth talking to about these bikes, he reckons he hasn't ridden his "regular" MTB for ages. I really must take him up on his offer for a test ride on one.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Best Mountain Bike