confused

I dont think at that end of the price range it makes too much difference so just pick one that you like the look of best.
I'm assuming all the bikes are in the same category ( all are hardtail mountain bikes)

They are all going to be running basically the same gear. Take them all for a test ride. There may be slight differences in their geometry and one will feel better than the others and that will be down personal preference. Even a quick lap around the car car will give you an idea.

The best fork idea is a good point and something a lot of people over look. Most people look at the rederaileur and some companies upspec this and cut cost elsewhere.

Just remember that the derailleur is relatively cheap to upgrade latter on and you'll more than likely break one and have to replace it anyway, where as better fork and better brakes will make far more difference to the ride

I'd go with your son - Giant always seem to have the best value components within most price ranges especially if you are going around 1200 - plus I think they still do a 10 year warranty on the frames (could be wrong here). I started off with a budget Giant and I still use it today as a back up bike.

thanks for the input, yeah I've decided giant and they now actually have 35yr warranty on frames so pretty hard to go wrong aye,,, hope to see yous all on the trails.
Cheers

Make sure you shop around the giant dealers in newy, you've got Breakaway Cycles at Morriset and Spocks Spokes up at Salamander bay as well. Buying two bikes you should be able to get an extremely good deal on 2010 run out models, especially if it is floor stock and they want them out the door so the 2011 bikes can fill the floor.

last thread get the bike shop too set u up then take it for a spin then find a few stores that have the same bike & do a deal there ,are stores off loading 2010 bikes for a song , don't pay full price & get them to throw in bottle cage , bottle & helmets too , these are essential & if you don't like the seat ask them if that can be changed for you & also purchase padded bike pants or you can go lycra its up too you . Main thing is bike set up too so your ride can be of some comfort , good luck

That sounds like the typical hadleys deal. 2010 bikes should be going for anywhere from 20-40% off. At this time of year the wholesalers are really pushing to get the old stock out of their warehouses. Great time to buy a bike if you don't mind the previous years model. i just paid $1500 for my new roadbike, shoes, pedals, helmet, bottle cages, sox and a fit which had a retail value of $2300 for the lot. I had to drive to Sydney to pick it up but that only cost me $40 in fuel.