You are hereForums / By Discipline / Mountain (off road) / By Location / Australia / NSW / Northern Beaches / Northern Beaches Trail Advocacy / FAQs regarding bike track temporary closure

FAQs regarding bike track temporary closure


LadyToast's picture

By LadyToast - Posted on 22 February 2010

Just got this, no doubt lots of others will get one of these in the email shortly too.

Manly Warringah War Memorial Park

FAQs regarding bike track temporary closure

Monday 22 February 2010

What is happening?

It has come to Warringah Council's attention that parts of the shared track around Manly Dam are not technically approved for bike riding and as such, Council had no choice but to close those stretches of track to riders until the Plan of Management has reviewed bike riding in the park.

There are three stretches of track affected and the stretches of track affect a total of 2.17km of the circuit. Under the current Plan of Management bike riding is restricted to public roads, car parks and fire trails and includes the opportunity to use fire breaks. The narrow stretches of bush track, where riders have previously been asked to dismount when approaching bushwalkers, are not authorised for bike riding by the Plan of Management.

Signs were installed at each end of the affected sections saying ‘bike riding prohibited’. Adhesive stickers will also be added to maps of the Manly Dam, highlighting the sections of track that have been closed to bike riders.

It is anticipated Council will consider the temporary closure of the track for mountain bikers and the review of the Manly Warringah War Memorial Park Plan of Management at the Council meeting of 23 February 2010.

In the event there is a review undertaken of the Plan of Management the review process will canvas the views of all stakeholders regarding the appropriate future management of the Manly Warringah War Memorial Park, which is an important environmental and recreational asset for the community.

It is anticipated this process will take at least six months.

When does the ban start?

The track was closed on Friday February 12 following development of signage and communications planning. The announcement was circulated to all the stakeholders involved by emailing the press release, and signage was placed on the closed track on that day.

How long will the sections of track be closed for?

Council regrets the inconvenience to bike riders. Council is looking at all possibilities for providing safe access for bike riders. Currently the sections of track will be closed to bike riders until the Plan of Management for Manly Dam has reviewed bike riding in the park. It is understood that Councillors will consider the extent of a review of the Plan of Management at Council’s meeting on 23 March 2010.

A review of the Plan of Management is a very extensive public engagement exercise involving all interested groups in the community. It is anticipated this process will take at least six months.

Why has this happened now?

It has happened for two reasons - Council is concerned about safety issues and following a review of the Plan of Management, also became aware that parts of the recreational track around Manly Dam are not approved for bike riding and as such, had no choice but to close those stretches of track to riders until the Plan of Management has reviewed bike riding in the park.

The narrow stretches of bush track which were considered to be unsafe were closed as soon as practical following the council briefing.

Council as a public authority and manager of land is under a duty of care at common law to take all reasonable steps to avoid foreseeable risks of injury to visitors lawfully using land for which it is responsible. This duty applies particularly if Council has actively encouraged and invited specific recreational uses as it has in relation to walkers and bike riders at Manly Dam. Further, if a specific risk of injury is brought to Council’s attention it is imperative that Council can demonstrate that it has considered how to best manage that risk and has then taken reasonable steps to do so.

Will Council be policing the bans and handing out fines?

Council will be monitoring the sections of track closed to bike riders.

Are you expecting bike riders to use the Wakehurst Parkway instead?

We are not in a position to recommend any alternate routes and naturally Council regrets the inconvenience caused to bike riders. Bike riders will have to make arrangements for starting and finishing where the track is no longer connected, similar to other tracks that do not provide a circuit.

Is the track still open to bushwalkers?

Yes it is.

What is a Plan of Management?

A Plan of Management provides a framework for managing public land. It sets a direction which Council and the Community have developed through consultation and research.

cambowambo's picture

here
... and now emailed to the "closed in the wet" mailing list.

ido09s's picture

i dont often respond in this manner but what a croc of shite....

"Council is concerned about safety issues", hows about some honesty and tell us that your worried about being sued!!! The only safety issue you have now is a bushwalker tripping over the extremely unfit for walking terrain, someone busting a limb falling down a rock drop or someone smashing their teeth as they slip on a wet board walk!!!

"Are you expecting bike riders to use the Wakehurst Parkway instead?" Of course they wont say yes because that will open them up to possible court cases should someone get hit!

I propose we all begin riding the Wakehurst Parkway during peak hour at 10kph, groups of 10 setting off every 2 minutes.

Has anyone been out to ride the Dam since the closure and actually walked the first bit of single track? Are the bushwalkers actually using it now that we are not allowed to ride it?

herzog's picture

That's bollocks.

Using that reasoning, they should:

Ban surfing at Fairy Bower (rocks and sharks you see).
Ban all surfing when the swell hits 6ft.
Ban riding bicycles along the beachfront - since it's far busier than the dam.
Ban skateboards just about everywhere.
Ban people jogging at above 15kph - same typical speed as enclosed singletrack riding.
Ban golf - whacking small projectiles at 300kph in the vicinity of other people.
Ban roadies - I saw a pack of them burn through a red traffic light outside a school at 40kph this morning.

Thing is, I have taken part in all of these sports, and the actions of this council seem to be very prejudiced against one in particular.

12+ years of precedence is proof that this venue is safe and would be extremely hard to argue against in court.

herzog's picture

Maybe they should do a study tour of Rotorua?

That's a council junket I WOULD support.

Lach's picture

"Simple" solution would be for council tonight to endorse a temporary approval of mtb riding on the disputed sections of track while the POM review takes place. Mtb and walker access to affected parts of the track can be clearly specified as "at your own risk", with appropriate temporary signage. The POM review can then take as long as it takes and will provide an opportunity for a decent debate about mtb use and mtb / walker interaction, long term trail sustainability etc.

However, on the evidence to date, "simple" solutions would be starting from the outside barrier and carrying a punitive weight.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
Best Mountain Bike